Immigrants’ names as an initial factor of discrimination

A field experiment reveals social Integration difficulties for people with names of a foreign origin

Cornel Nesseler, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NTNU
Carlos Gómez-González, University of Zurich, UZH
Helmut Dietl, University of Zurich, UZH
Adaptation: Xavier Aguilar

Taking advantage of football’s popularity, a field experiment was conducted on immigrants’ access to social activities. The experiment consisted of posing as football fans applying to take part in a trial training session for an amateur team and sending emails to coaches at over twenty thousand clubs all over Europe. Despite the applications being identical, those sent as if from footballers with local names obtained more affirmative responses than those sent with names of a foreign origin. In the case of Spain, the preference in favour of native players was evident: the difference was of thirteen points, standing above the European average. The results reveal difficulties for social integration that, subsequently, may also lead to barriers relating to labour and economic integration.
Key points
  • 1
       From email accounts with profiles clearly identifiable as either locals or immigrants, messages were sent applying to take part in a trial training session with an amateur football team.
  • 2
       Applications from foreign nationals received less attention than those from native players, both in Switzerland and, more markedly, in Spain.
  • 3
       Name-based discrimination affects newly arrived immigrants and second- and third-generation immigrants alike.
  • 4
       The research will be extended to some twenty European countries and will enable analysis of the differences in results between countries and whether there is a tendency to penalise names from certain origins more.
Ratio of affirmative responses by name origin in Spain
Ratio of affirmative responses by name origin in Spain

Applications sent to local football clubs signed by names such as Daniel Rodríguez or Pablo González, referring to a clearly native origin, obtained a positive response in practically half of cases. In contrast, only just over a third of those signed by names of foreign origin, such as Youssef Alami, were successful.

 

Classification

Authors

Cornel Nesseler , Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NTNU
Carlos Gómez-González , University of Zurich, UZH
Helmut Dietl , University of Zurich, UZH
Adaptation: Xavier Aguilar

Tags

Subject areas

Related content

Article

The transition to post-compulsory education among students of immigrant origin in Catalonia

Some 23.5% of pupils of immigrant origin leave school in the transition between compulsory and post-compulsory education. We analyse the differences by pupils' migration status and sex.

Article

Why are there more early school leavers among migrant-background young people?

What role must teachers play to combat early leaving from education and training of young people of foreign origin? This study shows that their support is key and that they must count on the necessary resources for guiding pupils.

Article

The presence of immigrants in local politics is well below their demographic weight in Spanish society

Do municipal councils in Spain reflect the diversity of origins of the population? We analyse access to local politics for immigrants and whether differences exist between the different foreign groups.

Best practices

CURANT

What to do with young, unaccompanied refugees who at the age of 18 have their state tutelage removed? In Belgium, they voted for a comprehensive individualised accompaniment and support from young native people with whom they are co-housed.

Best practices

Neighbourhood Mothers

Through the training of immigrant mothers, so that they can act as “neighbourhood mothers”, this action, carried out in Denmark, is successful in transmitting to women from ethnic minorities their rights and obligations in the host country.

You may also find interesting

Article

Presence of foreign footballers and its impact on attitudes to immigration

Presence of foreign footballers and its impact on attitudes to immigration

Social Inclusion

Can football alter opinions on immigration? According to this study, among a club’s followers, when the team wins thanks to foreign players, immigration is perceived more positively.

Article

Temporary work and self-employment have a negative impact on workers’ wellbeing

Temporary work and self-employment have a negative impact on workers’ wellbeing

Social Inclusion

Is the gig economy threatening workers’ wellbeing? The rise in temporary and self-employment, favoured by the digital platforms, seems to be affecting quality of life.

Article

Do fathers spend more time with their children than they used to?

Do fathers spend more time with their children than they used to?

Social Inclusion

According to this study, in comparison with the year 2002, in 2010 there was an increase in the time that mothers, and even more so fathers, devoted to their children. Despite this, the gender gap persists.