What do we know about the taxes we pay? And does knowing more change the way we think about redistribution?

Dirk Foremny, Universitat de Barcelona
Winning article of the Call to support social research projects based on the conducting of surveys, 2019.

Results from a large survey experiment in Spain (the study surveys 6,000 respondents) show that people have major misperceptions about the level of taxes they pay and the level of government that sets tax rates and receives revenues. Respondents underestimate their true tax burden and are mostly unaware that the autonomous communities have a substantial degree of autonomy to change the tax rates. In the experiment, the survey provides the correct information about the tax system to some participants, who can then be compared to those who did not receive this information. The results show that the effects of this information are sizeable. After the treatment people prefer a more progressive tax system, think differently about inequality, and become more opposed to tax evasion.
Key points
  • 1
       The study documents a sizeable bias in what citizens believe about their tax payments and the level of government that receives the revenues.
  • 2
       In general, people are in favor of redistributive policies. Respondents regard inequality as problematic, believe the poor should pay less tax, and would choose a progressive tax system over any alternative.
  • 3
       Providing the true information about the tax system during the survey increases the support for redistributive policies. This is shown by evaluating the effect relative to a control group which did not receive additional information.
  • 4
       People who learned about their true tax burden during the experiment are in favor of an even more progressive tax system. The experiment shows that they would tax the rich with a tax rate 3 points higher compared to the control group. Respondents who received the information about the autonomy of the autonomous communities to change tax rates were more likely to regard inequalities as a serious problem.
Public opinion about the level of taxes on the poor
Public opinion about the level of taxes on the poor

Classification

Tags

Subject areas

Related content

Article

Regularising the situation of the immigrant population does not result in a “call ef-fect”

What were the consequences of the regularisation, in 2005, of 600,000 non-EU immigrants who were working in Spain? This study reveals that it did not lead to any “call effect”, but did lead to increased tax revenues.

Report

The redistributive effects of the system of taxes and transfers in Europe

We analyse possible reforms, considered in a pre-covid-19 scenario, for improving the welfare state in Spain and its redistributive capacity in relation to the European average.

Report

The redistributive effects of social benefits and taxes: a review of the current situation

The situation in the coming months forces us to reflect on our society's (pre-covid-19) redistributive capacity. Spain is one of the EU countries with the greatest income inequality.

Infodata

Inequality in income distribution

Between the years 2007 and 2017, inequality in Spain increased, with a Gini Coeficient (not including social transfers) that has increased in value from 45 to 50

Infodata

Level of economic development

The GDP in purchasing power standards allows a more exact comparison of the level of economic development between countries. In 2017, the GDP per inhabitant in Purchasing Power Standards remained at 92% of the European average, unchanged from the previous year

You may also find interesting

Infodata

Disproportionate housing costs

Disproportionate housing costs

Social Inclusion

Some 30.4% of people of foreign origin live in households in which their housing costs exceed 40% of their disposable income.

Report

Long-life societies confronting the challenge of long-term care

Long-life societies confronting the challenge of long-term care

Social Inclusion

What does long-term care represent for societies with increasing life expectancy? We analyse the research that exists on this issue.

Infodata

Employment rates of the population (aged 24 to 64)

Employment rates of the population (aged 24 to 64)

Social Inclusion

Does being an immigrant influence employability? Judging by the data, yes, and prominently: in 2018, the occupation rate of the foreign population in Spain with higher education was 9.2 points below that of the native population.